Welcome to Mama Mia 44 SW
At Mama Mia 44 SW, we celebrate the rich traditions of Italian and seafood cuisine in the heart of New York City. Born from a passion for authentic flavors, our restaurant creates a warm, inviting ambiance that merges casual charm with classy elegance. Guests can savor handcrafted pizzas and exquisite seafood dishes, all while enjoying accessible services like outdoor seating and a variety of vegan and vegetarian options. With a commitment to inclusivity, we offer features such as Braille menus and gender-neutral restrooms. Our story is one of community, flavor, and a genuine love for food—perfect for families, friends, and gatherings.
- 621 9th Ave New York, NY 10036 United States Hotline: (212) 315-4582
Welcome to Mama Mia 44 SW, a delightful culinary haven nestled in the heart of New York City at 621 9th Ave. This establishment masterfully blends the vibrant flavors of Italian cuisine with an undeniable seafood twist, providing a menu that promises a satisfying experience for every palate.
At Mama Mia 44 SW, dining is more than just a meal; it’s an experience steeped in warmth and friendliness. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between casual and classy, making it suitable for everyone from families enjoying a cozy dinner to groups celebrating special occasions. With options for indoor and heated outdoor seating, guests can choose their preferred ambiance while indulging in delectable dishes.
- Diverse Menu: The menu is a true highlight, featuring a remarkable variety of dishes that cater to vegetarians and vegans alike, ensuring everyone finds a favorite. Imagine savoring a fresh seafood pizza or a delectable pasta paired with your choice of sauce—every bite is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to high-quality ingredients.
- Accessibility: Mama Mia 44 SW takes great pride in its accessibility features, including an ADA-compliant entrance and restroom facilities. This consideration for all guests ensures a welcoming environment where everyone can enjoy a great meal.
- Community-Centric: As a women-owned business, Mama Mia 44 SW embraces inclusivity and community spirit. Whether you're dining with dogs or children, enjoying happy hour specials, or looking for catering options, this restaurant has you covered.
- Convenient Services: The restaurant excels in convenience, offering reservations, takeout, and delivery services. Plus, with payment options from Apple Pay to Venmo, dining here is hassle-free.
As I took my first bite of their signature seafood pizza, the symphony of fresh ingredients ignited my taste buds. The crispy crust, perfectly seasoned sauce, and succulent seafood toppings were nothing short of divine. It’s clear that the chefs at Mama Mia 44 SW pour their heart and soul into every dish they create, as each offering reflects both tradition and innovation.
In a city teeming with dining options, Mama Mia 44 SW stands out as a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists. With its good-for-groups approach and a menu that embraces both simplicity and sophistication, you'll find this restaurant a perfect choice for any occasion. So, gather your loved ones, unwind, and let your taste buds embark on an unforgettable Italian seafood adventure.
Don’t forget to call ahead at (212) 315-4582 to secure your table—you won’t want to miss out on this culinary gem!

Had the most amazing experience at this restaurant today. We just happened to walk in and were made to feel very welcome. The server was extremely nice and helpful and mindful of my kids allergies. We ordered the pasta bolognese and Chicken ...

Started by the owners parents over 50 years ago as a onewindow pizza shop, this establishment located on the southwest corner of 44th St in Hells Kitchen is where my partner and I decided on an early dinner Saturday night as firsttimers ...

Came across this fabulous place as we were walking to grab dinner on our last night in the city. So glad we stopped here! Connie greeted us with a smile and we were immediately seated. She shared some family stories and laughs with our ...

If youre looking for an authentic family owned restaurant in NYC this is the place! Mama Mia not only has excellent food but the staff is friendly and we felt like family. The owner and her daughter took the time to talk through the wine ...

Had the pleasure of dining here on a visit from London last week with a girlfriend. I shall be honest we intended to to eat elsewhere but came across this place just passing by. The location was ideal and the staff very attentive. I had the ...

This was our second time coming here and the food was amazing both times! The staff was very friendly and family owned which made it even better. I highly recommend this place

Was out and about and found MamaMia on the way back to the hotel. The place was nice and cozy. Lasagna tasted great. The homemade bread was roasted to perfection. The cheese pizza also tasted great. Overall, it was a great little restaurant authentic to NYC. I will return to eat here. Great staff!!!

This was our second time coming here and the food was amazing both times! The staff was very friendly and family owned which made it even better. I highly recommend this place

Had the pleasure of dining here on a visit from London last week with a girlfriend. I shall be honest we intended to to eat elsewhere but came across this place just passing by. The location was ideal and the staff very attentive. I had the ...

Came across this fabulous place as we were walking to grab dinner on our last night in the city. So glad we stopped here! Connie greeted us with a smile and we were immediately seated. She shared some family stories and laughs with our ...